The story of Ruth Ellis, the last woman to be hanged in Britain, has returned to public attention following renewed debate sparked by the television drama A Cruel Love: The Ruth Ellis Story.
Legal experts say the case remains one of the clearest historical examples of how domestic abuse was misunderstood and overlooked by the justice system with new calls for a posthumous pardon.
Ellis was convicted of murdering her lover, David Blakely, whom she shot outside a London pub in 1955. At her trial at the Old Bailey, the jury was not permitted to fully consider a defence of provocation, and she was subsequently executed. Decades later, her family continues to argue that her conviction represents a miscarriage of justice, citing the severe domestic abuse she endured during the relationship.
Family lawyer Rayner Grice from national law firm Clarke Willmott LLP says the case must be viewed through a modern legal lens.“What Ruth Ellis experienced would today be recognised as a sustained pattern of controlling and coercive behaviour,” Grice explains. “Her relationship was marked not only by physical violence but by psychological domination, including isolation, intimidation and control over her daily life. These are now clearly understood as hallmarks of domestic abuse.”
Evidence presented in later accounts of the case points to repeated assaults by Blakely, including violence that led to Ellis suffering a miscarriage. Legal analysts argue that such context was not given appropriate weight at the time, reflecting a broader failure in mid-20th-century courts to recognise the cumulative impact of abuse.
It was not until the introduction of the Serious Crime Act 2015 that controlling or coercive behaviour became a specific criminal offence in England and Wales. The law acknowledges that abuse is often not a single incident but a pattern of behaviour designed to dominate another person, carrying a maximum sentence of five years’ imprisonment.
Grice notes that many of the behaviours now criminalised were present in Ellis’s relationship. “We now understand that abuse can involve financial control, threats, monitoring communications, and undermining a person’s sense of reality through gaslighting,” she says. “Victims may be isolated from friends and family or made to feel dependent and powerless over time.”
According to Grice, these patterns remain highly relevant in modern family law cases.“We frequently see individuals who are afraid to come forward because they believe they will lose their children or financial security,” she says.“That fear is often reinforced by the abuser as part of the control.”
While public discussion has traditionally focused on female victims, Grice adds that awareness is growing around male victims of coercive control, particularly in disputes involving child arrangements.“The courts are increasingly alert to these dynamics, but early specialist advice is critical,” she says.“It can make a decisive difference in how cases involving children and finances are resolved.”
Legal protections available today include non-molestation orders, occupation orders and other forms of injunctive relief designed to safeguard victims quickly. However, Grice emphasises that recognising abuse remains a challenge.“Many victims do not immediately realise what is happening to them because the behaviour develops gradually,” she says. “By the time it becomes intolerable, they may feel there is no way out.”
The renewed attention on Ellis’s case has intensified calls for a posthumous pardon, with her family arguing that the legal system failed to account for the abuse she suffered. For Grice, the case carries a broader lesson.“Ruth Ellis’s story highlights how far the law has come, but also why vigilance is still needed. Where abuse is present, especially where children are involved, seeking expert advice at the earliest stage is essential.”
Clarke Willmott’s leading family law team is nationally recognised for its work in divorce, child arrangements and complex family and financial matters.
Speak to our team
To get in touch with Clarke Willmott’s specialist family law team please send an enquiry or call us on 0800 652 8025.
Posted:
